Forgot password?  |  Register  |    
User Name:     Password:    
Review   

Crimson Shroud Review


See PixlBit's Review Policies

On 02/16/2013 at 12:20 PM by Angelo Grant

You must roll an 18 or higher to enjoy this game. Roll 1 D20. Add an additional D10 if you enjoy RPGs in general. Additionally, add 1 D8 if you enjoy JRPGs, 1 D6 if you like tabletop RPGs, 1 D6 for western RPGs, and 1 D4 for MMORPGs. Finally, add +2 to your total if you’ve ever been LARPing.
RECOMMENDATION:

Recommended for those who don’t mind shorter RPGs, lengthy encounters, and want to experience a unique combination of tabletop and JRPG mechanics.

Have you ever played a tabletop RPG? If not, the formula in my abstract may sound like some sort of foreign language to you. Essentially, a tabletop RPG is a lot like a video game RPG but instead of a computer calculating random numbers, dice rolls determine all your actions. Will your attack hit? Roll some dice according to a formula. How much damage will it do? Roll another set of dice. Will the attack be critical? Roll again. You get the idea. You honestly can’t even eat a snack without rolling for initiative. It’s this problem that gave rise to the digital version of the RPG, which replaces dice rolls with random numbers generated by a computer.

Obviously the tabletop version of the RPG games predates our digital equivalents by quite some time, but oddly enough, I can’t recall the two ever coming together to form a hybrid quite like  Crimson Shroud.  It’s an experimental take that practically reverses the trend most would associate with games like Baldur's Gate. It’s almost as if its creators took the thought process backwards, imagining what would happen if the digital RPG came first, and dice rolling was added, instead of taken away, to create the illusion of playing a board game. The results of this experiment are, in a word, debatable.

My main reason for calling this game an experiment is its length. Crimson Shroud is short. Very short. A single playthrough of the game will take around 10 hours, and an experienced player can likely take it down in 5. The game does have some built in replay value however, as it is designed to be played through twice. You will keep a fair amount of your loot for the second run, but the game will be more difficult and tactically demanding. Additionally, you’ll have some new dialogue and additional areas to explore that were previously unavailable.

So how do the hybrid game styles come together? Well, it starts with map exploration. In Crimson Shroud, I never feel like I was playing as a protagonist. Instead, I felt like I was role-playing a person playing an RPG under the watch of a dungeon master. This was reflected mechanically by the method by which I moved my party, which was done by selecting their destination by moving a marker on a map instead of walking from one position to another.

The story telling method also helped with this illusion. Long text scrolls explain the story in the sort of richly detailed language you’d expect from someone who put endless thought into creating their world, and wants to impart as much of their vision as possible. Needless to say, if a lot of reading in a video game bothers you as it did some who played Lost Odyssey, this may not be for you.

Occasionally, after selecting a location to move to, an event will take place requiring a dice roll to determine the outcome. For example, if you have the option to sneak past a group of monsters instead of fighting them, you’ll have to roll to determine if you’ll be successful. There’s no trickery here from what I can tell; you’re actually rolling a set of true virtual dice, and the system actually has fairly realistic physics that respond the same way you’d expect real dice to. It’s a neat feature that made me feel like I took a greater role in the system’s determinations.

Where dice rolls really get involved is in the combat. At face value, it’s a standard turn based JRPG. Each turn allows a character to perform a skill, and to either cast a spell or attack. The dice rolls add flavor to this by determining bonuses, or in some cases, chances to hit. I enjoyed this quite a bit at first, but after a while, I began to wish for a way to speed things along, especially in the second half of the game when encounters became fairly lengthy. Fortunately, unlike its tabletop cousin, you don’t roll dice for everything, but you will roll them a couple of times per round, especially if you choose to add bonus dice to a command from your stash.

Now, about that stash of dice. As per usual, spells and skills are often assigned an element, which is either strong or weak against other elements. Elemental skills and spells can also be chained together to earn bonus dice. In short, each elemental ability adds another icon to a chain on the bottom of the screen, so long as the element in front of it is not weak to the element that’s being cast, or the element was not already used earlier in the chain.

From the third link upward, each additional element chained earns you a bonus die, which has more sides depending on how far it is up the chain. For example, link 3 will earn you a D4, link 4 will earn you a D6, and so on. These can be multiplied by using a spell called “Dice Lure” which adds +2 to dice sides per level, so Dice Lure would turn link 3 to a D6, and Dice Lure 2 would change it to a D8. These dice can then be rolled to add points to damage or chance-to-hit on attacks or spells.

After resolving an encounter, you get to pick your loot. Here again your stash of dice takes on another role (see what I did there?) and, depending on how well you perform in battle, you’ll be given a number of points to spend on selecting your spoils, but you may not have enough to grab everything you want. If that’s the case, you can cash in your earned dice to add points to your total, with the amount of points being determined by how many sides a die has. Since you have a limited number of slots to hold these bonus dice, you can’t hoard them up then spend them on a super expensive item, you’ll have to build up your chain, and spend your smaller dice in battle to keep room available for your larger dice. This is all very important since Crimson Shroud has no levels and your characters only grow stronger based on the equipment they use.

The artistic styling, story, and music all convey the spirit of its creator Yasumi Matsuno. Anyone who has played any of his past works will find themselves in very familiar territory. The soundtrack is instantly reminiscent of Final Fantasy Tactics, while the story speaks of hidden political agendas and secret religious histories with a distinctly eastern European flair.

Don’t expect much in the way of animation however. This game is designed to give you the feeling of playing with the painted miniatures commonly used in tabletop games. While there may be changes in character placement or camera angle, that’s as dynamic as it gets, so don’t come here expecting Final Fantasy style visuals for attacks and spells. The same goes for the use of 3D. It gives a great diorama viewpoint on the playing field, but since nothing really moves very much, I only occasionally moved the slider up to take a peek at how things looked, then turned it off again.

This game also has one very irritating problem. At one point, you’ll have to rely on an item an enemy may drop in order to advance. First of all, the game doesn’t give you any hints as to how to advance, so you have to almost randomly stumble upon the solution, or look it up online. Second, you have to handle the encounter in a specific way to get the enemy you need to kill to spawn. Finally, it’s still not guaranteed that the enemy will even drop the item. I ended up stuck at this point for 5 hours before I resorted to looking up the solution online, and even then I still had trouble getting the item to actually drop. It’s a shame, because aside from this flaw, the game is very solid.

Recommending a title like Crimson Shroud isn’t easy. While I personally enjoyed the novelty of rolling dice, it absolutely causes the encounters to become lengthy, and when grinding without benefit is required on top of that, it can make the experience a drag. Since the majority of the game is spent in combat, that’s a pretty defining factor, and you may not even know if it’s something you can tolerate until you try it out yourself. Its $7.99 price point puts it in an odd spot as well, since you may feel ripped off if you don’t enjoy the game. The best I can do as a reviewer is let you make the call based on what I’ve told you, and hopefully you can make a thoughtful decision based on this information that’s better than a random roll of the dice (Ha! Did it again!).

Review Policy

In our reviews, we'll try not to bore you with minutiae of a game. Instead, we'll outline what makes the game good or bad, and focus on telling you whether or not it is worth your time as opposed to what button makes you jump.

We use a five-star rating system with intervals of .5. Below is an outline of what each score generally means:


All games that receive this score are standout games in their genre. All players should seek a way to play this game. While the score doesn't equate to perfection, it's the best any game could conceivably do.


These are above-average games that most players should consider purchasing. Nearly everyone will enjoy the game and given the proper audience, some may even love these games.


This is our middle-of-the-road ranking. Titles that receive three stars may not make a strong impression on the reviewer in either direction. These games may have some faults and some strong points but they average out to be a modest title that is at least worthy of rental for most.


Games that are awarded two stars are below average titles. Good ideas may be present, but execution is poor and many issues hinder the experience.


Though functional, a game that receives this score has major issues. There are little to no redeeming qualities and should be avoided by nearly all players.


A game that gets this score is fundamentally broken and should be avoided by everyone.


 

Comments

Julian Titus Reviews Editor

02/16/2013 at 03:43 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

I got a total of 19. I was able to roll for everything except for LARPing, but I had a critical failure on the d20. 

Angelo Grant Staff Writer

02/16/2013 at 04:48 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

my formula worked then! Excellent! I seriously doubt I'll ever top that abstract.

Honestly Julian, if you ever end up getting a 3ds, I think you'd love this game.

Julian Titus Reviews Editor

02/16/2013 at 05:54 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Yeah, it sounds like Knights of Pen and Paper on iOS, which I have Jesse and Mike to thank for.

asrealasitgets

02/23/2013 at 07:56 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Thank you for the write up. I really enjoyed the game. Most of the games on eShop don't stand out that much, but this game really shines, for me anyway. I have dabbled in table top gaming, so I was familiar with dice rolls and such. I loved the fact that it was short! I just don't have as much time as I used to for playing lenghthy games. I want more shorter games. I agree with the random key item drops. This game is a bit odd if you're not used to "real" old school gaming. I didn't mind the lengthy text either. That's how some roleplaying games are sometimes. It's good! I would recommend.

mothman

02/24/2013 at 03:57 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Angelo,

You get a full 5 stars for that first paragraph alone. Nice write up. I want to check this game out.

Angelo Grant Staff Writer

02/24/2013 at 04:37 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Well thank you sir!

Dandichu

02/25/2013 at 10:58 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Great review! I personally am having a really hard time getting into this game... but I'll give it another shot. xD

JadedDragos

03/25/2013 at 10:38 AM Reply | Permalink | Report

If I did this correctly, and I may not of. I am a bit rusty, I broke out my dice and I got 26? Who knows. I love this game though, stuck on it at the moment, but still trying. Laughing

Log in to your PixlBit account in the bar above or join the site to leave a comment.

Support

Hot Story

Dark Souls II Review

Masochistic is a word often associated with the Souls games. Though they’re known to be incredibly difficult for anyone who may be new to the series, they’ve become only mildly challenging for veterans. However, Dark Souls II is no pushover, proving to be difficult as soon as the journey begins. Even in the most basic tutorial area, players will find death waiting for them. Whether you fall into a hole you overlooked or walk past an enemy who is able to catch up to you for an easy backstab, Dark Souls II isn’t afraid to kill you mercilessly. Although the game never feels cheap, it always finds a way to lure me into a well sprung trap in which I am ill-prepared for. Difficulty isn’t the only thing in which the Souls franchise is known for though, and Dark Souls II gives us another beautifully crafted world that’s perfectly ripe for exploration with rippling lore waiting to be uncovered and dissected.

Read More...