Forgot password?  |  Register  |    
User Name:     Password:    
Review   

Xenoblade Chronicles Review


See PixlBit's Review Policies

On 04/27/2012 at 12:15 PM by Angelo Grant

A truly rewarding experience
RECOMMENDATION:

Highly recommended for any Wii owner that enjoys RPGs

These days, same old same old just does not cut it.  When an RPG from Japan comes around that promises to be different, the modern gamer is understandably cynical. Thankfully, with a unique world, a fresh take on in game relationships, and an excellent use of in game rewards to encourage the player, Xenoblade Chronicles delivers the refreshing changes and modernizations many of us have been looking for.

As in any game, players need a goal to accomplish, a threshold to cross, a bar to fill, and some reward to justify doing what they are doing. Xenoblade simply showers the player with a myriad of both simple and intricate systems loaded with goals, accomplishments, and incentives. Progress notifications appear at a clip I’ve never personally experienced in an RPG before.  Almost every action you take results in some increase of some stat toward some goal or reward, and the only time the game feels weak is when something interrupts this steady flow of accomplishments.

Launching an assault in Xenoblade feels very much like it does in MMORPGs like World of Warcraft, but with a shot of adrenaline.  While my experience with MMOs is somewhat limited, I can say that the brawls in Xenoblade feel tighter, faster, and more responsive. In another call to the genre’s online cousin, each character has a hotkey bar, here called a battle palette, which you can customize outside of combat to suit your needs. Each attack (earned automatically as characters level) has a cool down period, keeping you from spamming attacks, and agro is drawn based on your actions in battle.  It isn’t too much of a stretch to say this is a refinement of Final Fantasy XII’s combat system, except it gives the player far more control over their individual actions, and does so at a faster clip.

The AI (you only control the lead character, which you can change) does a good job of remaining competent, and troublesome situations are actually telegraphed to you via visions, which work in tandem with the story.  Before an enemy unleashes a special move, or does something that ends the life of one of your party members, the screen will flash to a colorless cinematic showing you what’s going to happen.  It gives you an opportunity to warn your AI companion to prepare them for what’s coming, or cast a buff that may negate the attack. 

The floodgates really open when you get your hands on a controller though.  Selecting the icon to launch an attack brings up a very simple quick time event.  Timing it properly gets you an advantage.  Further advantages come in a similar fashion in the midst of combat, where you can encourage your teammates and boost their affinity with each other, as well as temporarily bolster their statistics for that particular encounter.

There is a temporary impediment to experiencing this system in its full glory.  At first, it’s rather confusing to remember which icon on the battle palette leads to the attack you want, and while descriptions are provided when the icons are highlighted, the clock never stops ticking. This gets more confusing when using the Monado blade, as the weapon has its own sub menu which consists entirely of linguistic characters in a foreign language.  It becomes second nature eventually, and as mentioned earlier, the menu can be customized to your liking, but it can be a little daunting when you first pick it up.

Xenoblade is gorgeous from the instant you fire it up. The first thing that will appear is a title screen with the titular sword displayed, apparently abandoned and embedded in the ground ala Final Fantasy VII, with a prompt to press any button. I strongly advise against doing so right away, as you will miss some of the most amazing music you’ve ever heard. Xenoblade features the music of Yoko Shimomura and Yasunori Mitsuda, and both have clearly brought their A-game.  

Exploration is also heavily rewarded, and not just by viewing the breathtaking scenery.  Discoveries of new locations give you experience and sometimes generate landmarks on your maps that you can select to travel to at will.  In addition to this, each area has its own unique score, and these themes change based on the time of day.  Daytime themes are appropriately upbeat and energetic, while night time brings on more melancholy tones with an air of mystery.  It’s so good in fact, that my wife frequently mutes the game she’s playing to listen to the Xenoblade score.  The last time she did that, I was playing Nier.  In that respect, discovering the game's themes and vistas is an additional reward in itself.

The day and night cycle is a neat feature.  A clock is featured surrounding the world map on your HUD indicating the time of day in the game world, and the environment cycles appropriately from sunrise to sunset. Different monsters will appear on the landscape based on not only this, but the weather as well. This could have caused problems if you picked up a quest to take out a nocturnal enemy and started at daybreak, but you can change the in-game time on the fly.

Quests are typical, but plentiful and also baited with a plethora of rewards.  The tried and true Kill X trash mobs, Eliminate named monster Y, and find item Z objectives are all there, but they can be accomplished with little getting in your way.  A majority of the quests will resolve themselves while you roam the area filling out your map and completing other direct objectives.  Additionally, quite a few of the quests don’t require you to check back in with the requestor, and simply drop the reward directly into your inventory.

There is another type of item finding quest, however, that was a little annoying.  While exploring, you’ll encounter glowing blue spheres on the ground, and picking them up will give you a random item that can only be gathered this way.  These items can be used to fill up your “Collectopedia” which will grant you a reward each time a category or area is completely documented, and some NPCs will ask for them in quests.

This isn’t a problem when it's flowing along with your natural play of the game, but it can really put a stopper into the steady stream of rewards if it doesn’t go quite right.  Too often I’ve had to run through a location multiple times because the needed pickup simply would not generate.  I appreciate that they tried to do something different than the standard quest types mentioned earlier, but I came here to kill mobs and grab loot, not to chase dots like Pac-man.  It’s not a deal breaking issue, but for the OCD players who want to do everything like myself, it can certainly be an occasional irritant.

Another hard stop is caused by the interface. It can take a frustratingly long time to number crunch equipment stats and make sure your characters have a good load out due to poor menu structure. It can take even longer if you’re trying to figure out what you want to sell to clear out space in your inventory, since the only way to truly evaluate your equipment against what the vendor is offering is to remove all slotted gems first. It takes quite a bit of time, and ends up breaking the steady clip of objectives with unnecessary monotony. 

These gems are Xenoblade’s simplified adaptation of the classic Final Fantasy VII Materia system. They can be fitted to slots on equipment to add stats and effects.  It’s not the crux of the game, and as such is relatively simple. Those wishing to invest further in the system can spend time crafting their own gems using items acquired by mining and harvesting enemy drops.  The process is somewhat time consuming, but unlike other distractions, this one is completely optional, and the game is very upfront about that.  In my own experience, I never felt the need to delve too deeply into gem crafting, as the gems I got from Collectopedia completion and quest rewards were more than sufficient.

The story is of the typical “save the world” variety, but with some interesting twists, such as the world being the cadavers of two monolithic beings that have slain each other.  As with the other systems in the game, there are points of genius that are sometimes offset by strange distractions.  One example would be some of the women’s outfits.  All the action takes place in the same game engine, including the cut scenes.  Since the best item for a female party member at the time happened to be bikini armor, that’s what she was clad in when an event that was intended to be very dramatic took place, leading it to be unintentionally comical.  Again, nothing horrible, and considering the game’s Japanese origins, such content is almost expected these days, but that doesn’t make it tasteful to the western palette.

There’s so much more this game offers.  There’s a tree menu leveling system that constantly and  automatically unlocks new bonuses based on which tree is equipped while your characters gain experience, there are bonus points that can be spent to level up individual skills, there’s a town you can rebuild, affinity to manage between your overall party and the various settlements you encounter, affinity coins you can earn which allow you to borrow abilities from other characters, relationships you can map and develop between NPCs... the list is almost never ending, and results in your effort almost always paying off in some way.  While it’s not perfect, it comes very close, and is a dramatic step up over similar games like Magnacarta 2.  If you own a Wii, and you enjoy RPGs at all, pick this one up.  You’ll be aptly rewarded.


Review Policy

In our reviews, we'll try not to bore you with minutiae of a game. Instead, we'll outline what makes the game good or bad, and focus on telling you whether or not it is worth your time as opposed to what button makes you jump.

We use a five-star rating system with intervals of .5. Below is an outline of what each score generally means:


All games that receive this score are standout games in their genre. All players should seek a way to play this game. While the score doesn't equate to perfection, it's the best any game could conceivably do.


These are above-average games that most players should consider purchasing. Nearly everyone will enjoy the game and given the proper audience, some may even love these games.


This is our middle-of-the-road ranking. Titles that receive three stars may not make a strong impression on the reviewer in either direction. These games may have some faults and some strong points but they average out to be a modest title that is at least worthy of rental for most.


Games that are awarded two stars are below average titles. Good ideas may be present, but execution is poor and many issues hinder the experience.


Though functional, a game that receives this score has major issues. There are little to no redeeming qualities and should be avoided by nearly all players.


A game that gets this score is fundamentally broken and should be avoided by everyone.


 

Comments

Anonymous

04/27/2012 at 03:16 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

solid review

Anonymous

04/27/2012 at 03:18 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

you left out all the hating bs good fr you

Matt McLennan Contributing Writer

04/28/2012 at 06:23 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Um, WHAT? Unlike MOST gaming media sites we don't slather our writings with shit like that.

If you are the same anonymous user that crapped on our Operation Rainfall roundtable piece, do us a favor and spare us your "JRPGS ARE BEING CRAPPED ON!" shit. God.

Anonymous

05/01/2012 at 07:44 AM Reply | Permalink | Report

I am complimenting your article. Dont be a douche bag

Travis Hawks Senior Editor

04/28/2012 at 05:14 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Sounds pretty awesome. Guess I should pick it up.

Matt McLennan Contributing Writer

04/28/2012 at 06:23 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

You should pick it up. ;)

Kathrine Theidy Feature Writer

04/29/2012 at 03:04 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

I'm not really sure what the "moderization" comment means in the opening paragraph, but if it in some way is saying that an action-based battle system is an evolution of a turn-based one, I take real issue with that. But this is probably not the place to open that can of snakes.

In any case, I agree with just about everything besides calling this game a change instead of being something different. I don't think I've been this into an RPG since Chrono Trigger, I've just been wandering around the world and seeing what kind of stuff I can find.

The battle system was engaging for a while, and provided some new options once I got some more members, but now I'm wishing that I could control my party members. They don't always do what I want themt to, especially Melia. The CPU uses her pretty badly. Oh well, I guess with a long game like this, things wear thin everntually, but the battle system could be a little deeper. It's still fun a majority of the time though.

I would have to disagree about the game being gorgeous. Though there are a few nice scenes in the game, most areas are plagued with blurry textures, and the character models are extremely blocky. If cutscenes didn't get so close to the characters then that wouldn't be an issue, but the graphics are sometimes so bad that it's distracting. I'd have taken fogging for some more visual clarity.

I agree about the interfaces and such, though the game has taken some steps towards streamling things, there's still more it should have done. One would be adding a bestiary, something most other RPGs have. This would make finding monsters you already found easier when you get a side quest for them.

I'd say most of this game's issues are only issues if you want to complete it 100% (or as 100% as possible), but since it's all optional stuff, the main story is mostly free of problems. 4 1/2 stars is probably what I'd give the game, too.

Angelo Grant Staff Writer

04/30/2012 at 10:53 AM Reply | Permalink | Report

Actually, I'm very glad to see this feedback.  If you see things that need an explanation, it's reasonable to assume plenty of others do, and it gives me an opportunity to respond.

My modernization comment is not at all referring to action over turn based combat.  I feel there is a place for both.  I recently played probably 80 hours of Etrian Odyssey III and was completely in love with the game.  I feel this is an evolution of the action / cool-down style action RPG games that are starting to appear this generation, although they have yet to receive a designation.  I'm sure you know what I'm talking about though, it's a reason that people compare games like this to MMOs.  Korea actually has a lot more of them than Japan, probably because of their love of MMORPGs, and it's the reason I compared it to Magnacarta 2 in the closing paragraph.  

I too, would have loved this game to be in a higher fidelity, but that just isn't in the cards for a Wii game made in 2010.  To be honest, I was never as distracted by the cutscenes as you were, and was focusing more on the English voice acting than the characters.  As far as the rest of the game goes, I would perhaps commit atrocities to get this game in HD, but platform aside, I don't know if this was ever something that could have happened to Xenoblade. I think the cost to develop a game of this magnitude in HD would have been too much for the game to handle, and the product would have suffered for it in the end.  I'm happy getting the great game I got, even with the technical limitations.

I do think the game knows this weeknesses though, and compensates admirably. While a lot of the textures do look pretty poor up close, they look great at a distance, and the viewable area and amazing scenery aren't hurt by that.  In fact, I think the designers did a great job of drawing your eye to the landscapes and vistas that make the game shine. Arriving at the end of an early quest that left you on a cliff side overlooking Colony 9 forces you to stop and stare.   Seeing the swamp turn into an ethereal light show at night was another high point of the experience, and appearing on the Bionis knee and seeing that expanse spread out in front of you was breathtaking.  I couldn't help but compare that last moment to arriving on Pulse in FF XIII, only it occurred so much earlier in the game.  I do think the game is gorgeous, although limited, and I think it knows it's limitations and distracts you from them well.

Mongoose

05/01/2012 at 02:55 AM Reply | Permalink | Report

*ahem*

If you're want to get some Xenoblade HD action, someone's got you covered.

http://forums.dolphin-emulator.com/showthread.php?tid=22102

its a work in progress,so take that for what its worth. Of course, there's the whole ISO/ROM issue, so yeah, don't condone piracy, buy the game, let NOA know you give at least one #$#@, you know the drill.

Log in to your PixlBit account in the bar above or join the site to leave a comment.

Support

Hot Story

"Keep"ing the Identity of Dragon Age Intact

The Dragon Age series has something of an identity crisis, due in large part to its disjointed development history. Even though Dragon Age: Origins came out a couple of years after the first Mass Effect, it was actually announced way back in 2004 as a PC exclusive. The roots of Origins could be found in BioWare’s classic Baldur’s Gate series, and the design sensibilities of the game were far removed from the company’s more recent action/RPGs like Jade Empire and Mass Effect. Dragon Age 2 was clearly very influenced by the success of Mass Effect 2, and the input of now BioWare parent company EA was easy to see. While Dragon Age 2 alienated some fans of Origins it also created a new set of people invested in the world of Thedas. Now we have a third entry in the series that has the difficult task of keeping old players invested while trying once again to do a “soft reboot” of the franchise. How does BioWare hope to craft a new adventure but still make players feel like they made their mark on the world? Enter the Dragon Age Keep.

Read More...