Forgot password?  |  Register  |    
User Name:     Password:    
Review   

Killer is Dead Review


See PixlBit's Review Policies

On 10/01/2013 at 12:00 PM by Nick DiMola

Let’s all put aside our preconceived notions and take a critical look at Suda51’s latest effort.
RECOMMENDATION:

For Suda51 fans and anyone who can appreciate an anime-inspired action game.

Misogyny. It’s a word that’s been thrown around in tandem with Killer is Dead since the fated Gigolo Mode was first revealed. However, creator Grasshopper Manufacture has gotten a raw deal. This tongue-in-cheek mode (that only features two unique encounters) has thrown the stars completely out of alignment for the studio and the game at large. The fact of the matter is, Killer is Dead is quite similar to Suda51’s past works. Combining the frantic action of No More Heroes with the third person shooting from Shadows of the Damned and the darker atmosphere offered by Killer7, Killer is Dead is a fantastic fusion of some of Suda51’s oeuvre. The cryptic narrative that undercuts the experience further accentuates the charm of this excellent action game.

Yes, indeed – this is an excellent game. I know that might be hard to believe given some of the reviews you may have read, but it is the truth. I typically don’t explore other reviews before I write my own, but given the controversy, they were nearly unavoidable. I spotted plenty of claims that the game performs poorly from a technical perspective, that the combat was shallow, and that the story made no sense; however, I found these claims to be wholly unsubstantiated. Let me explain.

The tale of Killer is Dead revolves around protagonist, Mondo Zappa, an apparent executioner whose memory has been lost. After waking up one day, he decides to join the Bryan Execution Firm for unknown reasons. What quickly becomes clear is that Mondo is a simple guy, with some very simple motivations. He is dedicated to doing his job and doing it well, and he’s a ladies’ man – much like James Bond, a clear archetype for Mondo’s character.

It’s true that not much makes sense in the world of Killer is Dead up front. “Wires” from the dark side of the moon have infected a subset of people, which remove most of their facilities and send them on insane killing sprees. Bryan (head of the execution firm) is consistently accepting contracts and sending Mondo off to take care of the worst wires. In these individuals, the wires infection has manifested in drastic ways, turning many into unimaginable monsters capable of so much more than a common man. Despite how absurd this seems, it all works within the context of the world.

I liken the story of Killer is Dead to movies like Memento and Donnie Darko. While plenty of details are laid out in front of you to detail the subtext of the story, it’s up to you to observe the clues and piece together the bigger picture. This is part of the magic of the narrative and part of the reason why I love the game as much as I do. Certain segments of the plot are still shrouded in mystery and all of the pieces can be put together in much different ways, but there’s already some incredible discussion around the imagery in the game and what it all means (Warning: Links Have Spoilers). If you love a story that challenges your perception of the obvious and forces you to think, you too will appreciate the craftsmanship that went into the tale of Mondo Zappa.

Even if the story holds little intrigue for you, there’s arguably enough in the tightly constructed action to keep you engaged from beginning to end. Much like the levels in No More Heroes, Killer is Dead has players slicing and dicing their way through a bunch of low level enemies before taking on the big boss at the end. These enemies in large part are fodder for experience points to purchase upgrades for Mondo, as well as points to upgrade your blood meter and your health. They double up as a training exercise to gain mastery of certain techniques before heading off to the much more challenging boss encounter.

What’s most interesting about the combat in Killer is Dead is that it really has three levels of complexity, but mastering all is not necessary for success. At the most basic level, you can hack and slash almost all of the enemies to death and brute force your way through every mission. I fear that many people playing the game will never progress beyond this level of execution because it is a strategy that can be successful. On an intermediate level, you will master blocking, dodging, and parrying. This opens opportunities to attack enemies rapid-fire and allows you to build up your combo meter, which speeds up Mondo and allows him to tear through enemies faster and faster until the combo ends. At the highest level of execution, players will learn to master the adrenaline mode and take down enemies quickly and efficiently for the highest possible grades on missions.

Admittedly, I managed to make my way through the entire game without ever reaching the highest level of mastery, but the various challenges that unlock as you beat episodes forced me to reconsider my strategy and begin performing at a much higher level. When I eventually tackle the game again, I plan to head back through with my newfound skills and achieve the highest ranks.

All that being said, the place where Killer is Dead really shines is in the boss encounters. Many are sprawling and grand and all of them are unique in their own way. In the very first encounter you’ll fight a giant bug that crawls along the walls and forces Mondo to break out his arm cannon to knock it from the ceiling in order to slice it up with his sword. As you go along, the encounters become more and more challenging and force you to produce a unique strategy for success. This is done through observation, pattern recognition, and experimentation – the makings of a great boss battle.

Of course, the varied worlds and unique settings make for a visually stunning game. From an Alice in Wonderland house, to the Zen space of a Japanese Garden, to a runaway train in the snowy mountains of Russia, there’s never a mundane outing in Killer is Dead. Presented in a psuedo-cel-shaded art style, the unique settings are most definitely eye-catching. There is some intermittent screen tearing, but never enough to be distracting. There are also some technical hiccups here and there, particularly when new parts of the level are being loaded, but again nothing that truly detracts from the experience.

So, I’ve put it off long enough at this point, but let’s touch on Gigolo Mode. I know that the de facto response to it is utter disgust for its vile exploitation of women, but in reality, this is a ridiculous overreaction.

When the mode starts, Mondo is hanging out at the bar, having a drink and he notices the “beauty” a few seats down. He heads over and starts talking to her. It’s your job as the player to sneak a glance at her chest (which offers only slight cleavage) to build up your “guts” meter. Once the meter is full, you get on one knee and give the beauty a present. If she falls for you, the game cuts to a video where it’s implied that she stays the night. And that’s the whole thing that everyone has gotten so upset about.

In my opinion, the entire sequence is kind of goofy, and truth be told, not too far off from reality. I mean, one-night stands never happen, right? Of course not. Let’s not kid ourselves about this – Gigolo Mode is nothing worse than a depiction of something that happens quite frequently at bars all over the world. Coupled with the lighthearted tone of the whole thing and the fact that you spend about ten minutes with the mode in the entire game, I really don’t understand what people have gotten so upset about. I think it’s a harmless addition, but I’ll let you be the judge.

As much as I want to tell everyone to run out and grab Killer is Dead right away, it’s hard to make such a suggestion. While I don’t feel that other reviewers have given the game a fair shake, the reality of the matter is that Suda51 games aren’t for everyone. They’re weird and cryptic and, at times, offensive. In my opinion, he is a true auteur of this medium, but that inherently makes his works less accessible than your typical AAA game. If you already know yourself to be a fan of his work, you absolutely can’t go wrong with his latest effort. All others should take heed that this is a distinctly Japanese game that makes very little effort to cater to Western sensibilities. If you can accept and appreciate that, Killer is Dead just might draw you into the niche fandom of Grasshopper Manufacture.

Review Policy

In our reviews, we'll try not to bore you with minutiae of a game. Instead, we'll outline what makes the game good or bad, and focus on telling you whether or not it is worth your time as opposed to what button makes you jump.

We use a five-star rating system with intervals of .5. Below is an outline of what each score generally means:


All games that receive this score are standout games in their genre. All players should seek a way to play this game. While the score doesn't equate to perfection, it's the best any game could conceivably do.


These are above-average games that most players should consider purchasing. Nearly everyone will enjoy the game and given the proper audience, some may even love these games.


This is our middle-of-the-road ranking. Titles that receive three stars may not make a strong impression on the reviewer in either direction. These games may have some faults and some strong points but they average out to be a modest title that is at least worthy of rental for most.


Games that are awarded two stars are below average titles. Good ideas may be present, but execution is poor and many issues hinder the experience.


Though functional, a game that receives this score has major issues. There are little to no redeeming qualities and should be avoided by nearly all players.


A game that gets this score is fundamentally broken and should be avoided by everyone.


 

Comments

transmet2033

10/01/2013 at 02:45 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

I am curious now.  I do not think that I have spent any time with a Suda51 game.  I was almost tempted to play Shadows of the Damned.  I may have to go and test a couple of those games.  I think tha I remember seeing Sine Mora will be on PS+ this month, may start there.

Pacario

10/01/2013 at 05:23 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

Concerning the "Gigolo Mode," I haven't seen it in action, but the criticisms against it probably belong to that same vocal minority that wails about GTA 5 and any other game that doesn't fit neatly within politically correct parameters. It's getting to the point where developers are going to be too afraid to create anything but safe, meaningless, vanilla-style content. Even more progressive games like The Last of Us have been attacked for sexism and the like.

*sigh* Video games have never had it easy. 

BrokenH

10/12/2013 at 06:59 PM Reply | Permalink | Report

That's what I love about Pixlbit. I find most of the reviews here are "fair" and keep "political correctness" out of the equation. Even when I disagree with reviews on this site, I can still understand why the reviewer in question felt the way he or she did because everyone here is articulate and decent enough at getting across their points.

I admit my big deterrent for most Suda 51 games is their length. Aka, they tend to run a bit on the short side. Still, I've been eying Lollipop chainsaw and Shadows Of The Damned quite longingly now they've dropped in price. lol.

One thing I enjoy about being an indie game-maker is that I don't have the pressure put on me to conform. It's admirable Suda 51 stays himself even with all that aforementioned pressure put upon his shoulders by the mainstream gaming media.

Log in to your PixlBit account in the bar above or join the site to leave a comment.

Support

Hot Story

Nerds Without Pants Episode 60: Risky Business

Welcome to the last regular episode of Nerds Without Pants of 2014! Since it is our last opportunity to talk about what media we’ve been consuming until January, we get together and…not really talk much about video games. Huh. Well, it’s a show, anyway.

Read More...