Ooo, that would be a good one. You could make each area of the game represent different lineups of the band. The Starless and Bible Black area could be a lightless dungeon in a castle infested with The Inquisition. Your object is to escape torcher and get out, kind of like Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay.
It was such an awesome resource. I like to look at all the games ever made in one massive database. I dont' know if anyone else has done this.
I'd like a game based around prog rock and set in the Court of the Crimson King. It'd be like that Dante's Inferno game but way less stupid. I mean, the gameplay could be all over the place and challenge the heck out of you with musical puzzles that require serious music theory knowledge or super trippy space travel sections where you shoot mind bullets at transgendered-clown-puti (flying baby angels). . . wait. Now I'm getting into avant garde. So nix the flying-baby-clown-transgendered-angels and replace them with a manticore. Yeah! A manticore. Love those things. 
Really though, you make a good point. The great games always have great music. Why not start there? Speaking of which, I just read that the Megaman series was conceived with music in mind.
It was kinda tongue in cheek really, but I wonder when the technology will let that happen.
What I like is that it goes back as far as you want. With Metacritic, it only goes back to like 2001 or so. I like a database that includes every game ever made. Yea!
That's cool. I'd do that someday.
On allgame.com none of the One Piece games got anything better than a 3 out of 5 stars.
I use wikipedia to give me an overview of a year in gaming. That's pretty cool, but for a complete list, you can't beat allgame.com.
It's alright. Seems most people use things like gamefaqs and stuff, but I don't know if they have such a easy to use and comprehensive database like allgame.com.
I've considered playing some of the One Piece games. Maybe they're fun?
